Advocates for college athlete compensation in California are on a hot streak. First the state passed a first-in-the-nation law allowing players to , and 20 states followed its example. Now, with both a recent U.S. Supreme Court decision and a National Collegiate Athletic Association rule change challenging the idea that students shouldn鈥檛 make money from athletics, legislators are pushing to move up the effective date of the California law to this fall and expand it to cover community college athletes.
鈥淭he amateurism ideals have been weakening over time, not only with just player movements, advocate movements, but also because of litigation that鈥檚 currently playing out,鈥� said Eddie Comeaux, a professor of higher education at UC Riverside who studies college athletics.
The NCAA has previously barred athletes from earning money for their performance, aside from scholarships. But the Supreme Court鈥檚 9鈥�0 ruling June 21 allows colleges to also cover as much as $6,000 per year in education-related expenses for athletes, such as laptops and study abroad programs. While it didn鈥檛 directly strike down the NCAA鈥檚 amateurism model, a concurring opinion from Justice Brett Kavanaugh signaled a willingness to do so, spurring hope among advocates that more avenues for player compensation could be on the horizon.
Then Wednesday, the NCAA announced that it won鈥檛 penalize athletes for taking advantage of state laws like California鈥檚 that allow them to profit from the use of their name, image and likeness.
鈥淲ith the variety of state laws adopted across the country, we will continue to work with Congress to develop a solution that will provide clarity on a national level,鈥� NCAA President Mark Emmert said in a press release.
鈥淭he Supreme Court鈥檚 ruling basically told the NCAA you鈥檝e got to follow the law, you鈥檙e not immune to antitrust, you cannot be a monopoly,鈥� said state Sen. Nancy Skinner, the author of the , which passed the California Legislature in 2019. She鈥檚 now pushing that amends the law to take effect Sept. 1, rather than in 2023. It passed the Assembly鈥檚 higher education committee this week, and would need to receive a two-thirds vote by the Assembly and be signed by the governor to become law.
State laws giving college athletes the ability to pursue money-making also went into effect Thursday in Georgia, Florida, Alabama, New Mexico and Mississippi.
College athlete endorsements on social media could eventually become a $2 billion dollar market, said Thilo Kunkel, director of the Sport Industry Research Center at Temple University and the founder of an app called Sprter, which helps players build and monetize their personal brands. Kunkel said his research found that the average college athlete with a few thousand followers could expect to make in additional income from social media endorsements.
鈥淢ost people won鈥檛 get rich off of them, but, you know, if you鈥檙e making $2,000 extra a year, it鈥檚 50 bucks a week, it鈥檚 a little bit here, it鈥檚 a little bit there,鈥� he said.
Athletes on the Sprter app can sign endorsement deals, sell social media shoutouts and book in-person experiences such as a training session with fans. It鈥檚 just one of a number of ventures already sprouting up as the new NCAA rules take effect this week. , twin sisters who play for Fresno State鈥檚 basketball team, told ESPN they had already signed their first endorsement deal with Boost Mobile on Wednesday.
Unlike the original Fair Play to Pay Act, Skinner鈥檚 new bill would afford California鈥檚 community college athletes the same freedom to profit from their name, image and likeness as their peers at four-year universities. The bill has the support of the California Community College Chancellor鈥檚 office.
鈥淪tudents should not have to sit by and watch others profit off of their hard work and labor without being equitably compensated for it, just because they participate in college athletics 鈥� and that includes our many community college student-athletes as well,鈥� spokesperson Rafael Ch谩vez said in a statement to CalMatters.
John Beam, the athletic director and head football coach at Oakland鈥檚 Laney College, said the inclusion of the state鈥檚 community college athletes would be a huge win. He said that while not all athletes will be able to take advantage of the money-making opportunities, it鈥檚 an important first step to restoring a sense of humanity to how college athletes are treated.
CalMatters is a nonprofit, nonpartisan media venture explaining California policies and politics.