老夫子传媒

漏 2025 | 老夫子传媒
Southern Oregon University
1250 Siskiyou Blvd.
Ashland, OR 97520
541.552.6301 | 800.782.6191
Listen | Discover | Engage a service of Southern Oregon University
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Catholic hospital in Eureka faces another lawsuit after refusing to perform an emergency abortion

Providence St. Joseph's Hospital in Eureka is facing lawsuits concerning policies on abortion.
Ellin Beltz
/
Wikimedia Commons
Providence St. Joseph's Hospital in Eureka is facing lawsuits concerning policies on abortion.

It鈥檚 the latest legal challenge to Providence St. Joseph Hospital鈥檚 abortion policy.

A woman who says she was denied an emergency abortion while miscarrying sued Providence St. Joseph Hospital in Eureka, California, this week.

Last year, Anna Nusslock arrived at St. Joseph bleeding and in severe pain after her water broke 15 weeks into her pregnancy. Doctors diagnosed her with preterm premature rupture of membranes and told her the twins she was carrying would not survive, according to the complaint.

Nusslock said doctors refused to perform an abortion, even though her life was in danger. The Catholic-affiliated hospital has a policy of not performing abortions when a fetal heartbeat is detected.

The lawsuit says St. Joseph staff gave her a bucket and towels for the bleeding and directed her to Mad River Community Hospital. There, Nusslock began hemorrhaging.

K.M. Bell, an attorney with the which is representing Nusslock, said the ordeal was traumatic.

鈥淪he was terrified, in fear for her life, that she was going to bleed to death,鈥 Bell said, claiming Nusslock has since been diagnosed with PTSD.

The complaint seeks monetary damages from St. Joseph and its parent entities and asks the hospital network to change its policies to prevent similar situations.

According to the lawsuit, not terminating Nusslock鈥檚 pregnancy when her life was at risk violated California鈥檚 Emergency Services Law. Attorneys also claim the hospital broke the state鈥檚 Unruh Civil Rights Act by discriminating in care against a pregnant person.

鈥淲e believe that hospitals should not be allowed to pick and choose which emergencies they treat based on ideology,鈥 Bell said.

In October, California Attorney General Rob Bonta , arguing the hospital violated state law. While the hospital initially agreed to provide abortions when a patient鈥檚 life is at risk, it has since moved to dismiss the case on First Amendment grounds.

In a statement, St. Joseph said staff provide life-saving medical interventions that may result in indirect fetal death.

鈥淎s a Catholic health care organization, we are transparent that we do not perform elective abortions,鈥 according to the statement.

Justin Higginbottom is a regional reporter for 老夫子传媒. He's worked in print and radio journalism in Utah as well as abroad with stints in Southeast Asia and the Middle East. He spent a year reporting on the Myanmar civil war and has contributed to NPR, CNBC and Deutsche Welle (Germany鈥檚 public media organization).
Public media is at a critical moment.

Recent threats to federal funding are challenging the way stations like JPR provide service to small communities in rural parts of the country.
Your one-time or sustaining monthly gift is more important than ever.